The questions here cover a broad range of topics, ranging from what Restructuring bankers do to the more technical aspects of debt and transactions with distressed companies.
1.How much do you know about what you actually do in Restructuring?
Restructuring bankers advised distressed companies - businesses going bankrupt, in the midst of bankruptcy, or getting out of bankruptcy - and help them change their capital structure to get out of bankruptcy, avoid it in the first place, or assist with a sale of the company depending on the scenario.
2.What are the 2 different "sides" of a Restructuring deal? Do you know which one we usually advise?
Bankers can advise either the debtor (the company itself) or the creditors (anyone that has lent the company) money. It's similar to sell-side vs. buy-side M&A - in one you're advising the company trying to sell or get out of the mess it's in, and in the other you're advising buyers and lenders that are trying to take what they can from the company.
Note that the "creditors" are often multiple parties since it's anyone who loaned the company money. There are also "operational advisors" that help with the actual turnaround.
You need to research which bank does what, but typically Blackstone and Lazard advise the debtor and Houlihan Lokey advises the creditors (these 3 are commonly as the top groups in the field).
3.Why are you interested in Restructuring besides the fact that it's a "hot" area currently?
You gain a very specialized skill set (and therefore become more valuable / employable) and much of the work is actually more technical / interesting than M&A, for example.
You also get broader exposure because you see both the bright sides and not-so-bright sides of companies.
If you're coming in with any legal background or have aspirations of doing that in the future, there's a ton of overlap with Restructuring because you have to operate within a legal framework and attorneys are involved at every step of the process - so that can be one of your selling points as well.
4.How are you going to use your experience in Restructuring for your future career goals?
See above. In addition to the legal and "better technical skills" angles, you can also use the experience to work at a Distressed Investments or Special Situations Fund, which most people outside Restructuring don't have access to.
Or you could just go back to M&A or normal investing too, and still have superior technical knowledge to other bankers.
There's no "wrong" answer as long as you don't say you have no interest in it in the future.
5.How would a distressed company select its Restructuring bankers?
More so than M&A or IPO processes, Restructuring / Distressed M&A requires extremely specialized knowledge and relationships. There are only a few banks with good practices, and they are selected on the basis of their experience doing similar deals in the industry as well as their relationships with all the other parties that will be involved in the deal process.
Remember that a Restructuring involves many more parties than a normal M&A or financing deal does - there are lawyers, shareholders, debt investors, suppliers, directors, management, and crisis managers, and managing everyone can be like herding cats.
Lawyers can also be a major source of business, since they're heavily involved with any type of Restructuring / Distressed scenario.
6. Why would company go bankrupt in the first place?
Here are a few of the more common ones:
- A company cannot meet its debt obligations / interest payments.
- Creditors can accelerate debt payments and force the company into bankruptcy.
- An acquisition has gone poorly or a company has just written down the value of its assets steeply and needs extra capital to stay afloat (see: investment banking industry).
- There is a liquidity crunch and the company cannot afford to pay its vendors or suppliers.
7.What options are available to a distressed company that can't meet debt obligations?
- Refinance and obtain fresh debt / equity.
- Sell the company (either as a whole or in pieces in an asset sale).
- Restructure its financial obligations to lower interest payments / debt repayments, or issue debt with PIK interest to reduce the cash interest expense.
- File for bankruptcy and use that opportunity to obtain additional financing, restructure its obligations, and be freed of onerous contracts.
8.What are the advantages and disadvantages of each option?
- Refinance - Advantages: Least disruptive to company and would help revive confidence; Disadvantages: Difficult to attract investors to a company on the verge of going bankrupt.
- Sale - Advantages: Shareholders could get some value and creditors would be less infuriated, knowing that funds are coming; Disadvantages: Unlikely to obtain a good valuation in a distressed sale, so company might sell for a fraction of its true worth
- Restructuring - Advantages: Could resolve problems quickly without 3rd party involvement; Disadvantages: Lenders are often reluctant to increase their exposure to the company and management/lenders usually don't see eye-to-eye
- Bankruptcy - Advantages: Could be the best way to negotiate with lenders, reduce obligations, and get additional financing; Disadvantages: Significant business disruptions and lack of confidence from customers, and equity investors would likely lose all their money
9.From the perspective of the creditors, what different strategies do they have available to recover their capital in a distressed situation?
These mirror the options that are available to the company itself in a distressed scenario:
- Lend additional capital / grant equity to company.
- Conditional financing - Only agree to invest if the company cuts expenses, stops losing money, and agrees to other terms and covenants.
- Sale - Force the company to hire an investment bank to sell itself, or parts of itself.
- Foreclosure - Bank seizes collateral and forces a bankruptcy filing.
10.How are Restructuring deals different from other types of transactions?
They are more complex, involve more parties, require more specialized/technical skills, and have to follow the Bankruptcy legal code - unlike most other types of deals bankers work on. The debtor advisor, for example, might have to work with creditors during a forbearance period and then work with lawyers to determine collateral recoveries for each tranche of debt.
Also, unlike most standard M&A deals the negotiation extends beyond two "sides" - it's not just the creditors negotiating with the debtors, but also the different creditors negotiating with each other.
Distressed sales can happen very quickly if the company is on the brink of bankruptcy, but those are different from Bankruptcy scenarios.
11.What's the difference between Chapter 7 and Chapter 11 bankruptcy?
A Chapter 7 bankruptcy is also known as a "liquidation bankruptcy" - the company is too far past the point of reorganization and must instead sell off its assets and pay off creditors. A trustee ensures that all this happens according to plan.
Chapter 11 is more of a "reorganization" - the company doesn't die, but instead changes the terms on its debt and renegotiates everything to lower interest payments and the dollar value of debt repayments.
If we pretend a distressed company is a cocaine addict, Chapter 7 would be like a heart attack and Chapter 11 would be like rehab.
12.What is debtor-in-possession (DIP) financing and how is it used with distressed companies?
It is money borrowed by the distressed company that has repayment priority over all other existing secured/unsecured debt, equity, and other claims, and is considered "safe" by lenders because it is subject to stricter terms than other forms of financing.
Theoretically, this makes it easier for distressed companies to emerge from the bankruptcy process - though some argue that DIP financing is actually harmful on an empirical basis. Some DIP lending firms are known for trying to take over companies at a significant discount due to the huge amount of collateral they have.
One reason companies might choose to file for (Chapter 11) bankruptcy is to get access to DIP financing.
13.How would you adjust the 3 financial statements for a distressed company when you're doing valuation or modeling work?
Here are the most common adjustments:
- Adjust Cost of Goods Sold for higher vendor costs due to lack of trust from suppliers.
- Add back non-recurring legal / other professional fees associated with the restructuring and/or distressed sale process.
- Add back excess lease expenses (again due to lack of trust) to Operating Income as well as excess salaries (often done so private company owners can save on taxes).
- Working Capital needs to be adjusted for receivables unlikely to turn into cash, overvalued/insufficient inventory, and insufficient payables.
- CapEx spending is often off (if it's too high that might be why they're going bankrupt, if it's too low they might be doing that artificially to save money).
14.Would those adjustments differ for public companies vs. private companies?
Most of the above would apply to public companies as well, but the point about excess salaries does not hold true - it's much tougher for public companies to manipulate the system like that and pay abnormal salaries.
15.If the market value of a distressed company's debt is greater than the company's assets, what happens to its equity?
The SHAREHOLDERS' EQUITY goes negative (which is actually not that uncommon and happens all the time in LBOs and when a company is unprofitable). A company's EQUITY MARKET CAP (which is different - that's just shares outstanding * share price) would remain positive, though, as that can never be negative.
16.In a bankruptcy, what is the order of claims on a company's assets?
- New debtor-in-possession (DIP) lenders (see explanation above)
- Secured creditors (revolvers and "bank debt")
- Unsecured creditors ("high-yield" bonds)
- Subordinated debt investors (similar to high-yield bonds)
- Mezzanine investors (convertibles, convertible preferred stock, preferred stock, PIK)
- Shareholders (equity investors)
"Secured" means that the lender's claims are protected by specific assets or collateral; unsecured means anyone who has loaned the company money without collateral.
For more on the different types of debt, see the LBO section where we have a chart showing the differences between everything.
17.How do you measure the cost of debt for a company if it is too distressed to issue additional debt (i.e. investors won't buy any debt from them)?
You'd have to look at the yields of bonds or the spreads of credit default swaps of comparable companies to get a sense of this. You could also just use the current yields on a company's existing debt to estimate this, though it may be difficult if the existing debt is illiquid.
18.How would valuation change for a distressed company?
- You use the same methodologies most of the time (public company comparables, precedent transactions, DCF)...
- Except you look more at the lower range of the multiples and make all the accounting adjustments we went through above.
- You also use lower projections for a DCF and anything else that needs projections because you assume a turnaround period is required.
- You might pay more attention to revenue multiples if the company is EBIT/EBITD A/EPS-negative.
- You also look at a liquidation valuation under the assumption that the company's assets will be sold off and used to pay its obligations.
- Sometimes you look at valuations on both an assets-only basis and a current liabilities-assumed basis. This distinction exists because you need to make big adjustments to liabilities with distressed companies.
19.How would a DCF analysis be different in a distressed scenario?
Even more of the value would come from the terminal value since you normally assume a few years of cash flow-negative turnaround. You might also do a sensitivity table on hitting or missing earnings projections, and also add a premium to WACC to make it higher and account for operating distress.
20.Let's say a distressed company approaches you and wants to hire your bank to sell it in a distressed sale - how would the M&A process be different than it would for a healthy company?
- Timing is often quick since the company needs to sell or else they'll go bankrupt.
- Sometimes you'll produce fewer "upfront" marketing materials (Information Memoranda, Management Presentations, etc.) in the interest of speed.
- Creditors often initiate the process rather than the company itself.
- Unlike normal M&A deals, distressed sales can't "fail" - they result in a sale, a bankruptcy or sometimes a restructuring.
To be continued...